Federal Judge: Enough With the Stupid Names

Here’s more on the whole name discussion…(Thanks, Fareeda, for sharing) 

After Judge Cabrera’s historic ruling, little Clitoria Jackson will likely undergo a name change.

(DETROIT) In a decision that’s expected to send shockwaves through the African-American community—and yet, give much relief to teachers everywhere—a federal judge ruled today that black women no longer have independent naming rights for their children. Too many black children—and many adults—bear names that border on not even being words, he said. “I am simply tired of these ridiculous names black women are giving their children,” said U.S. Federal Judge Ryan Cabrera before rendering his decision. “Someone had to put a stop to it.”  

The rule applies to all black women, but Cabrera singled out impoverished mothers. “They are the worst perpetrators,” he said. “They put in apostrophes where none are needed. They think a ‘Q’ is a must. There was a time when Shaniqua and Tawanda were names you dreaded. Now, if you’re a black girl, you hope you get a name as sensible as one of those.”  Few stepped forward to defend black women—and black women themselves seemed relieved.  It’s so hard to keep coming up with something unique,” said Uneeqqi Jenkins, 22, an African-American mother of seven who survives on public assistance. Her children are named Daryl, Q’Antity, Uhlleejsha, Cray-Ig, Fellisittee, Tay’Sh’awn and Day’Shawndra. 

Beginning in one week, at least three white people must agree with the name before a black mother can name her child.  “Hopefully we can see a lot more black children with sensible names like Jake and Connor,” Cabrera said. His ruling stemmed from a lawsuit brought by a 13-year-old girl whose mother created her name using Incan hieroglyphics.  “She said it would make me stand out,” said the girl, whose name can’t be reproduced by this newspaper’s technology. “But it’s really just stupid.” 

The National Association of Elementary School Teachers celebrated Cabrera’s decision.  “Oh my God, the first day of school you’d be standing there sweating, looking at the list of names wondering ‘How do I pronounce Q’J'Q’Sha.’?” said Joyce Harmon, NAEST spokeswoman. “Is this even English?” The practice of giving black children outlandish names began in the 1960s, when blacks were getting in touch with their African roots, said historian Corlione Vest.

But even he admits it got out of hand.  “I have a niece who’s six. I’m embarrassed to say I can’t even pronounce her name,” said Vest, a professor at Princeton University. “Whenever I want to talk to her, I just wait until she looks at me and then I wave her over.” Cabrera’s ruling exempted black men because so few of them are actually involved in their children’s lives.

Tell me what you think…

91 Responses to “Federal Judge: Enough With the Stupid Names”

  1. L. Says:

    I think this is gonna draw a lot of heat for the overwhelmingly biased perception of what names should be. Jake and Connor? Connor…? Hell no! Even though I understand and agree with the point, it shouldn’t have been delivered with such a judge judy attitude. Thus, my support is for the choice. Nobody will tell me what to name my child. Maybe those who breathed a sigh of relief should review the movie “Roots”, reconsider the judges tactics, and explore a more respectful end to the situation.

  2. David Moore Says:

    Yeah, I understand what they are trying to do, but the government has no right, and no business, dictating what a family can name a child. One more tool of control.

  3. believer Says:

    I do not like this law. I agree that you shouldn’t give your kid a name that nobody can pronounce. But I am a black woman. This law is against all black women.

  4. Anonymous Says:

    what about african african people. many of them have names of thier heritage and those names are nothing like what we are used to. will this law be stripping those people of thier pride of where they are from?

  5. Anonymous Says:

    Sounds like another attempt by the government to get us to conform to what they believe is right…However, the names do lead to stigmas that cannot be easily erased.

  6. Cass Says:

    Is this a real story?

  7. Kaz Says:

    Ok…as a teacher who has to regulary struggle with the names people give to their children, I can understand the frustration that this judge is speaking of. I think it is interesting that 3 white people get to decide if the name is “fit”. That I do not agree with at all. Some of the names folks as dishing out aren’t always the most flattering. When I ask my 5th graders, “What does your name mean?” They can’t even tell me…they have no clue. Sometimes its just a combo of momma and daddy’s names. A name is a title that you should be proud to wear. If you suggest people call you by something other than your title, you must feel some shame and embarassment. The other point I thought was interesting was that black men were exempt since so few are involved with their kids….YIKES! Truly a sweeping indictment of what people perceive to be going on in all black families or households!

  8. jade1908 Says:

    “If you suggest people call you by something other than your title, you must feel some shame and embarassment.” Can’t necessarily agree with that statement. My son’s name is Kyle, and wants to be called Mike (his middle name is Michael).

    I think I know what you saying, but I just wanted to throw that out there.

    Also, some people have said this story is not true. Even if it’s not. it definitely is a great discussion topic.

  9. Shawna D-Ash Says:

    Cass, I am with you, I don’t think its real…or it came from The Onion…a satirical newspaper….that’s a little on the side of unethical for a judge to utter such stereotyping comments

  10. wil Says:

    little by little, the gov takes our right away. the government job is to protect us from our enemy, keep our economic running smooth not to dictate what i should or should not do in my house, as long as I’m not hurting nobody.

  11. SS, Central NJ Says:

    This can’t be real… And if it somehow is, I’m completely appalled and I’m as white bread as you can get! This would just be yet another example of the government dictating what little rights we still have over our own dominion.

  12. anonymous Says:

    Where did the original story come from? I can’t find any information on the decision anywhere.

    Thanks!

  13. anonymous Says:

    I wonder if we can contact the judge ourselves to voice opinions. Does anyone know how we could get in touch with this judge or their office?

  14. Melissa Says:

    I was reading this and thought it might be semi-real until I got to the line that said it was a rule just for black women, and especially impoverished black women and that they had to have 3 white women agree with them. I was cracking up.

    Now having said that, the pure ignorance that goes into a lot of names should be stopped by us. There is unique and then there is stupid. My niece and nephew joked around when creating names for their family on our Wii game. My niece’s Wii name is BoonKeesha, her daughter’s Wii name is Li’qor and her son’s Wii name is Alizay. Funny when it’s a game but not so much when it is real.

    Nice satirical story. Thanks Lee!

  15. sista Elliott Says:

    hallejuah, some one has seen the light!!!
    God bless that judge..

    (and I speak for all teachers out there who have to pronounce these horrid names, day in and day out. Myself included…dwl)

  16. C Says:

    This story is not true! Ryan Cabrera is a singer! There are no federal judges by that name!

  17. Crystal Says:

    Funny, but not true. Ryan Cabrera is a singer and I googled “Clitoria Jackson” and the only thing that popped up was this site.

    You do make a point. The naming is completely outrageous. But let us not forget Pilot Inspektor, Fifi Trixibelle, Sage Moonblood, Audio Science, Moon Unit, Diva Thin Muffin. Moxie Crimefighter, and Jermajesty.

  18. Niki Says:

    While I do not agree with anyone dictating how, why or what we name our children, we as parents should be thinking a little further than “ain’t that cute?” These children have to apply to universities and employers later. If an employer can’t pronounce their name, they may feel their clients can’t or won’t either, therefore, that resume gets tossed in the trash before the employer reads the applicant’s qualifications. I’m all for unique names but let’s use some common sense here and give our children names that will actually be beneficial to them. Mixing “mom/dad” names for the sake of letting the world/neighborhood know who the baby’s daddy is, is totally outrageous. I don’t know if this is true or not, but as strong black people, let’s start leaving a better legacy for our children than the ones we’re currently leaving. We have to learn from our biblical ancestors; names will sometime dictate personalities. Great discussion topic. Think I will share this with some other “unique” folks I know :>).

  19. Alli Says:

    My 2 daughters have names that are combination of mine and their Dad’s and it’s not to let anyone know who their father is, it was a family decision to choose to give our children names to make them proud and to know that they were created in love, and their names are beautiful and not difficult to pronounce and my children get a lot of compliments about the beauty of their names and beam with pride when they explain the origin.

  20. Mona Says:

    Everyone has the right to name their children. This article is racist and so was the person that wrote it. This statement is to the person that wrote it. “GET OVER IT!!!!” Nothing will change. I will not be forwarding this article. It will be a waste of my time and so was responding.

  21. Michelle Says:

    As a african american woman I think this article is very racist & ignorant! You should be able to name your child whatever you want. I agree that some of the names are a little difficult to pronounce, but for whatever reason african american children, as well as white american children, are given their names to be proud of. For someone to have to give approval to what you want to name your child is ridiculous. And to say that the majority of black men are not involved in their children’s lives just is such a ignorant & racial statement. There are more black men in their childrens lives then what the media wants to give credit. We live in a sad, sad world. Who gives you the right to name anyone’s child? Wake up it’s alot more going on in this world that needs to be dealt with.

  22. Maria Says:

    While I also do not agree with anyone dictating how, why or what we name our children, we as parents have a serious and significant obligation when it comes to the selection of a child’s name. Children will be adults one day, having to go through life answering to that name and being subjected to preconceived ideas about them, sometimes sight unseen, based upon their moniker. I relate to the concept of not necessarily favoring mainstream names, but compassion and understanding should go into the naming of a child in recognition that their name is the only thing that will be with them from the time of their birth till the time of their death. It is a profound responsibility, not to be taken so lightly.

    I wholeheartedly agree that it requires thought and consideration. Being involved in a public industry and working with people, I find a lot of time is taken merely asking for the spelling of names, because in the interest of individuality and honoring a person’s uniqueness, I never take the spelling of someone’s name for granted. However, some parents have gone wholly overboard with creative spellings. For example, there is nothing wrong with naming a child “Lakeisha,” or “LaKechia,” but when a parent goes to the length of spelling it “La’aquee’shiea” or “L’aa’quieschiah” to make it different, they are putting a burden on both society and that child. I see it every day, and it hurts my heart to know what these children face. We deal daily with racism but never look at how we are labeled at our own hands in a manner that helps perpetuate the hate.

    In addition, to paraphrase a prior comment, children have to apply to schools and for jobs. Particularly on a job application, if the name is a challenge to spell or pronounce, that application or resume may get tossed before the employer even reads the qualifications. We need to be exercising some common sense here and giving children names that will actually be beneficial to them, leaving a better legacy for our children than the ones we’re currently leaving.”

  23. Yoshi Says:

    SNOPES.COM
    A great website to check the validity on any e-mail folklore.

    Yoshi

  24. Jamaar Says:

    Fake…

  25. Karen Brantley Says:

    One, I’m from the Detroit Metropolitan area and based on my determination to find whether the judge and his ruling exist, I found one Cabrera, a baseball player.

    Two, If a Federal judge ruled to indicate black women are unable to name their children without permission from three white women, he violates non- discrimination rulings.

    I wonder if a Federal Judge would place his job at risk by making a ruling that discriminates against a race and gender — women.

    Three, as a former teacher and employee in educational systems, I’m reminded of hearing a story about white children with different names, ie, SheTed but spelled Shit Head. Apparently, the mother was also receiving welfare payments. Women (and families) of various races and cultures receive aid. If they didn’t , children would not received food, shelter or clothing.

    Doesn’t the “alleged” ruling also discriminate against economic class?

    As some of the respondants indicated, we design interesting names and some are combinations of parent’s names, but I’m also reminded of a Jamie Fox character, She-nay-nay. He’s an entertainer! Too many laughed at his characterization of a black woman, who lacked sexual morals. In a sense, he perpetuated a stereotype.

    When I read the article, at first, I laughed, because I remember names and interesting spellings from my days as an educator. But with greater consideration, I realize the article isn’t funny! How many of you continue to denigrate, women, especially women of African descent in print. I did by laughing at the article.

    Since the article focuses on women of African descent and supports an insipid view, we need to think about what we find funny!

    Karen

  26. Kevin Says:

    First of all, there is no Judge Cabrera. Second, we all as citizens, law-abiding or not, know that a judge or legislature CANT do that.

  27. Anonymiss Says:

    Excuuuussssseeeee the hell out of me black people!!! We need to stand up for ourselves b/c why the fuck you don’t see this judge calling out white women like Gwenyth Paltrow for naming her daugther “Apple” or Paula Yates whose 3 kids names are fuckin “Fifi Trixibelle”, “Tiger Lily” and “Peaches”!!!! Or what about Shannon Sossaman for naming her son AUDIO SCIENCE!!! Like that’s shit’s any better than Bonquisha. At least those names are original no matter how dumb they may sound. And you mean to tell me that a black woman has to get permission from 3 WHITE WOMEN to name her mother fuckin child???? Oh Lawd, somebody please help me now!!! This is the most ridiculous shit I’ve ever heard to make race an issue as to why black childrens’ names are so crazy. Stupidity & ignorance are not immune to any race people!!!! Hello, there are stupid, ignorant, crazy, lazy, funky, ugly, retarded, fat, nasty, and just plain old dumb people in all shapes, sizes, colors, cultures, and religions. No one is better than another and for one man to make a decision in which he says will affect “all black women”, is beyond me. And what’s even crazier is that black folks are letting this shit happen.

    Then for him to say that black men’s opinions don’t matter b/c they’re not really involved in their kids’ lives anyway, is not only FUCKED UP, but immensely stereotypical. Like I said, ignorance don’t escape no one race and there are plenty of white men who are dead beats too. Come on America, this is why you need to get off your ass and vote!!! Because sooner or later, you won’t be able to breathe without asking permission from a white person first. Black people have come too far to start backing down now.

    Maybe he should’ve made rules against names that are obviously offensive like “Clitoria”. Ok, this is an obvious case of dementia or something. Or maybe allow only ONE apostrophe in a name and it must be useful and in its proper place. But to completely take away our God given right to name our children after 9 months of pure hell is taking it too far!

    Not just black women, but all women in general need to stand up for your rights and stop letting people bitch you. And vote, vote, vote!!!

    I hope this article is not true…

  28. JUS Says:

    How can a judge with the last name Cabrera (is that even English, I can’t pronounce it , but you dont see getting my boxers/panties in a fucking bunch) speak on how and what a black woman of all people can name her child.. Last time I checked men couldnt have babies, so why is it a concern to him. He shouldn’t be allowed to make ruling such as that. He’d really be upset if you knew my real name let alone my mothers’ too. He’s need to pump his brakes and stick to ruling criminals or something instead of worry about what another person names their child. Racist Bastard!! There are some white people that give their children fucked up names to but he aint saying shit about that is he? He got some nerve can anybody tell what court he in.. I would like to personally send him a letter with piece of mind attached to it and I aint even a mother

  29. Chezlisa McCain Says:

    I am an African American female who finds this law very segregated. We should be allowed to name our children what we choose to. I feel that, if your going to pass a law like this it should go both ways. This is just another way to control how the African American community. If we can’t have the freedom to name our generations then what did Martin Luther King Jr. fight for in the first place. We don’t need any Black Becky’s or Sue’s or Dillian’s or Hunter’s any more than we need Shaniqua’s and La’ Shawnna’a. If you can’t pronounce a name then ask them how instead of immediately dismissing us. I strongly feel that this new law is racist and should be anulled immediately.

  30. Jacqueline Says:

    This can’t be real. Can it? Seriously.

  31. Equal not Special rights Says:

    Well, this ruling can’t possibly stick. And Anonymiss you are right about the ridiculous names that famous folks give their kids.

    I agree that Clitoria is ridiculous and offensive in my opinion. I can only imagine the torture that child will endure in school and hope that she won’t bring a gun to school after years of abuse from her classmates because her parents named her after a female body part.

    It’s ridiculous to think that there would be a panel of white people to approve names. The article didn’t say they needed to be women. And yes a lot of the remarks in this article were racist.

    I don’t think ANYONE should have special rights. Black, white or anyone. My question is why isn’t there a White history month or a white college fund? Am I racist? Certainly not. Just pointing out a fact.

  32. Equal not Special rights Says:

    And by the way when my mother was in the hospital after having a baby the nurse came in to get the paperwork filled out for my brother’s name and the nurse was crying because the white woman in the last room just named her baby “Adolf Hitler” because “she wanted everyone to hate that baby as much as she did”.

    Do people even think?

  33. MoJo Says:

    I don’t believe this story is true at all. Someone out there wanted to be funny. I am black and my husband and I have 3 girls with Swahili, Japanese, and Hebrew names. I chose the names based on their meanings. And I do believe a person should be proud of their name Whether it is their first, middle or last name or nickname. My children are very proud of their names. It fits their personality. I agree, some of the names us black folks are coming up with are crazy and have no meaning at all but why target black folks? No one has anything to say to a person that comes from China, India, or who is Jewish with hard names to pronounce. Their applications or resumes are not getting thrown in the garbage either and you know why, because there is enough people from China, India and who are Jewish that hold positions of power that think enough of their people to hire them and give them a chance. Bottom line is, there are people out there that will always has something to say about black folks. Whether we name our kids Bob or Jabari or if we wear our hair straightened or in dreadlocks, whether we live in the ghettos or the suburbs. Black people, this should be a CLEAR indication to you that it is time for us to wake up!!! We need to start educating our kids, making them understand that we need to be in positions of power, and when we get there, we need to give each other a chance and when you are giving that chance, you need to appreciate it and work hard so that one day you can do the same for somebody else!!! Once we become more powerful and use the God given talent we were given, no one is going to care about how hard your name is to pronounce!!! When an employer hires an Asian person, they don’t care about their name, employers believe that Asians are smart and will make the cooperation money!!! Unfortunately they don’t thing the same about black folks unless we are speaking of clothes, jewelry or rap music!!!
    God bless ALL people, lets stop making a big deal over nothing and face what the real issues are!!!

  34. MoJo Says:

    In response to your ? Equal not Special rights, the reason why there is not a White History month or a White College fund is because first off, America teaches you everything there is to know about being white. Everything you learn in school is about what the white man has done since he has been in America. Bottom line is, America was build on the backs of black folks, and you wouldn’t know that or be interested in that fact if somebody didn’t make a big deal about it and force it down your throat one month out of every year. It is not something I really expect most white people to understand, especially if you never bothered to take the time to learn all the things that black people have done for this country and actually it is sad that you don’t know or realize all that black people has done for this country because it is not just Black history but American history. It’s ashame that it is not included in the everyday teaching that takes place in school. And no, it doesn’t make you racist it makes you ignorant. Ignorant to the fact that everybody deserves to be recognize for their contributions especially when we are talking about building up a country. Now, the Negro College Fund, proves my point exactly on why pick on Black Folks. There are tons of College Funds out there. Do you realize that our country gives immigrants millions of dollars each year to go to college in America, we give money for left hand people, low income people, students with high grade averages, students that have American Indian background, handicapped students. Why are you so upset that there is also a United Negro College fund? It is a non profit organization that if funded by donations. If it’s not a fund you believe in, don’t donate!!! In fact, if the fund provides low income blacks the opportunity to go to school and get an education and perhaps get a decent paying job, that is one less Negro on the corner ready to rob you……am I correct?! Why don’t you go and look up facts about Negro slaves and how they took the biggest, and strongest black man and in front of all the other blacks, beat him down to a pulp, till he was almost dead, and how they then beat the other black men to a pulp. So he would understand that he was NOTHING and so the rest would be afraid, would not dare fight back or disobey the slave master. How black women were raped, and then their babies were taken from them and was forced to go and work out in the hot fields the next day after giving birth. How families were split up, children were sold, husband and wives were broken up. You go look all the information up. And look how blacks were still being hung in the 50’s and 60’s in the south. And then you come back and tell me why it is so important for a young black child to know that their people had something to do with building this country. Black children need black history, they need to know that they are somebody and deserve to be someone great. White people need to know that this is our country too. We helped make it everything it is today. And lets not get into the American Indians!!

  35. Equal not Special rights Says:

    By the way Mojo when I was in school I learned all about white AND black and it wasn’t just in the month of February. Yes I agree that the black man held a VERY important role in this nation’s history. But at what point do you let go what may have happened to you ancestors and move on. I didn’t persecute any black folk and I highly doubt you were around back then so what’s it to you? I don’t appreciate having a college fund that my children will NOT qualify for based on race. That’s discrimination PERIOD.

  36. Equal not Special rights Says:

    We should have a White college fund. I bet I could find folks to donate to it. But then there would be an outrage because of discrimination. Well, it’s a two way street.

  37. mad Says:

    This is flat out racist!!!!!!!!!!!!! Look how they pointed out the fact that thre sister had 7 kids and survived of welfare or that Black fathers are no where around.

  38. yes!!! Says:

    I am an african american women in her 20’s. I have natural hair, and I’m very proud of my heritage. My opinion will actually surprise some.
    THANK GOD SOMEONE THOUGHT OF THIS!!!!!!!!
    I work in the service community for the government let’s just say. Everyday, I see the most out of control names in the world. I makes me wonder, are they serious??? I mean, they are sabotaging their children before they can even talk. These parents need to realize that their children will one day apply for jobs. I’m in aggreance with this totally. And what makes it worse, when you misprounounce the name, the mothers have the nerve to get an attitude. Wow! Wake up black people!!!!!!
    We get mad when they stereotype us, but how about stop acting stereotypical????????
    Don’t get me wrong, I’m no wanna be, and I could sit here and type a bunch of mumbo jumbo that I know as well about black history, but I’m going to keep it real. I’m sure our ancestors wouldn’t be happy about how ignorant we act.

  39. Cheryl Says:

    Good lord, people….don’t you recognize BULLSHIT when y ou see it??

  40. yes!!! Says:

    Now, what i want to clarify is, I don’t know what gives “3 white people” the authority to say what’s good and what’s bad in a name of an african american child. If anything, let 3 african american people decide that. I don’t agree with that, but stopping all the ridiculous names, I agree with. There’s is going to be a lot of controversy behind this though, sounds like this is violating human rights.

  41. MissKris Says:

    What I name my child is no one’s business but mine and his father. I agree that we need to stop with the ridiculous names and “Q’s” tho. If you’re going to revert to our roots to find a name for your child, make sure it makes sense and has a positive meaning. the 22-yr-old they spoke of, Uneeqqi, started off with a questionable start. I wonder if she is real, as well as her kids, Daryl and ‘dem!
    In any case, I was teaching for a while and can understand the frustration as well as many. I hate to pronounce anyone’s name wrong. But if its spelled Qukifeadah, what should I do??? All I ask my sisters to do is think about how your child will feel in the future when s/he is introducing themselves. I know a guy who actually said “I dont know what my mother was drinking or smoking when she named me.” Now think of how his “future wife” will look at his mom when they first meet after hearing a comment like that from her own son. Just think about your kids ladies. Think about it…
    Peace and Blessings…

  42. Catherine Says:

    I found this website with some more information about the case: http://thepeoplesnews.wordpress.com/2008/03/18/condi-calls-for-removal-of-detroit-%E2%80%98naming-rights%E2%80%99-judge/

    It does seem to be real.

  43. Catherine Says:

    That was suppose to say It does not seem to be real.

  44. Robyn W. Says:

    I thought that we were living in 2008? There is no way on God’s green earth am I going to allow anyone to tell me what I should name my child. I admit that some of these names are ridiculous and being a teachers aide the names are a bit difficult for us black people as well. Who is this MAN to say before we name our chldren it has to be approved by 3 white people. Are we resulting back to the JIM CROW LAWS!!! As a black woman and mother i feel really hurt and offended by these remarks. It is the most racist comment that i have heard i na long time. How can he be allowed to do anything like that? And where are our Black Leaders to fight this nonsence.

  45. legaleagle Says:

    I have a hard believing this is a true story. A judge would not have made a ruling requiring 3 white people to approve the names of Black children. If that isn’t racist I don’t know what is… wake up people!

    It is your right as a parent and an American to be able to name your children whatever you want no matter how stupid that name may be. Shame on you if you name your child something ridiculous. I will share with you this quite a few of the Biblical names would be considered ridiculous based upon this article .i.e. Oprah which we all know has become a house hold name.

  46. mikiwik Says:

    I am an african-american woman, and I have one daughter named Lauren. We all must admit that there are some names that are way out of control, however, it is, and should be, an individual choice. This is America. The fact that the name must be validated by 3 “white people?!?” I couldn’t believe what I was reading!?! Where was this judge when you had “white” celebrities naming their children “Apple” and “Moxie Crimefighter”?

  47. mikiwik Says:

    I did go to the article and saw that the article was actually satire, but it does make you think. My sister-in-law was a Middle School English teacher, and the names that she would come back to us with would bring tears to your eyes at the thought of someone being so clueless, thoughtless, or insensitive to what these children will go through not just in school, but in buisness, and for the rest of their lives.

  48. Archie Says:

    Yeah. I don’t agree with the way judge Cabrera put it, although some of these names have to come to a stop. Alize?? Lexus, Mercedes, diamond. These are supposed to be aliases for strippers. Leave them for them!! And for those who want to name their children after african countries??? Sierra, Kenya, Egypt….. Even if you have something to do with that country. These countries have many human names that you can choose from. Ever heard of anyone naming their child USA?? I have not seen even one patriotic person do this. Stick to names. You can be creative, yet simple and unique. Uniqua??

  49. Stephon Says:

    This is really ridiculous, our ancestors had to get their names from the white man now they trying to bring it back. They call us African American so do yourself a favor and take a look at some African names I bet you can’t pronounce them either, let’s look at some Japenese, Chinese, Korean, Hispanics, or any other race or nationality that reside and go to school in the country with names that them same teachers can’t pronounce. Maybe we need to really look at the education level of the teachers. On the first day of school just have each student stand up and introduce themselves then you won’t look like a damn dummy. And while we at it what kind of name is CABARERA.

  50. emack06 Says:

    This is rediculous, the government, or a judge for that matter, has no right to tell people how to name their children. It is a God given right and no man has the power to take it away. Furthermore, This is a racially charged decision that should ultimately lead to that jugde being removed from the bench and possible brought up on civil rights violation charges. As far as the names “not being words”, well, I have never seen Jeff, David, Pam, Amy in the webster dictionary, thus they also are not words.

  51. emack06 Says:

    Whos to say those african countries weren’t named after people? Archie.

  52. Cynthia Says:

    Is there a copy of an official ruling on this or are “we” perpetuating another urban legend?

  53. Michael Says:

    I do agree with the judge saying that something has to be done to stop this “wierd” naming issue. However, I don’t agree with his method. What really needs to happen is improving are educational system in the U.S. This above all else must happen. Now lets talk about the judge’s idea. I mean. …. is it necessary that three white people decide on the name first? How about three college educated people instead. Can the three also be black also? Or better yet how about at least one of the three be male and college educated. If this judge says that black males are not around to assist in the naming of the child then he should at least allow a black educated male to take part in his “idea” for resolving this problem.

  54. regina Says:

    THIS IS NOT TRUE ITS HOAX come on people we are more intelliigent than that to believe something so ridiculous Please Do Not BELIEVE everything on the Internet

  55. emack06 Says:

    Well sista Elliott, If you cant pronounce a name, should you even be teaching?

  56. Melissa Says:

    You all do know that this article is untrue right? There is no federal Judge named Ryan Cabrera. This was written as satire.

  57. Jocy Says:

    Please make sure you put a disclaimer on stories like this. People unfamiliar with the legal processes in our country may think this is true. I received it in an email. My friend thought it was funny but she (thankfully) questioned it’s aunthenticity. As a law student, I pay several hundred dollars a credit hour to learn about the Constitution and related subjects. A federal judge cannot impose such a restriction. As a matter of fact, no judge can unless the constitution is rewritten. This would be a First Amendment case plain and simple.

    I do, however, think it’s important for people to think before they name their children. Randomly throwing letters together just won’t do.

  58. OP Says:

    Haha! I can’t believe that people are dumb enough to fall for my hoax! This is on at least 20 blogs now! Keep spreading it you morons!

  59. Dee Says:

    What’s more amazing to me than the story is the fact that people don’t recognize satire when they see it.

    Wowser…I mean…I have a lovely bridge in Brooklyn for sale if some of you are interested.

    Geesh.

  60. Niecee Says:

    I must say there are some names that i have to work hard at pronouncing and writing in my profession (assist teacher) and I just wanna know how long some of them are b4 they can SPELL their own names?
    I have 5 year olds who have no idea how to spell it and i have to grab a roster to provide them with an example…

    Now i admitt it should be a parent’s right to name a child whaever they want, but be reasonable, the child does have to be able to spell and recognize it right??

    Being named after cars and colors and whatever your heart desires has it’s limits, but that should be a common sense thing!

  61. KT Says:

    Those that believe this nonsense have obviously been “punked.”

  62. Missie Says:

    This article is a hoax

  63. Nobedine Says:

    My aunt named me Nobedine from her name Arbidine. I
    am very proud of my unual name and have gotten a
    lot of compliments all of my childhood and is still getting compliments today in my ADULT years! I was a teacher
    for over (30) years and I didn’t have any problems with
    the names of my students, no matter what their name were. TEACHERS GET OVER IT AND DO THE JOB YOU WERE HIRED TO DO! EVERY JOB HAS ITS UPS AND DOWNS, AND
    AND IF THIS IS THE ONLY PROBLEM YOU HAVE ON YOUR JOB, QUIT COMPLAINING AND TEACH YOUR STUDENTS HOW TO
    READ/WRITE/ AND DO MATH!
    The Racist person that suggested this needs to WORRY ABOUT ALL OF HIS OR HER WONDERFUL, DEDICATED,
    FELLOW AMERICANS, WHICH IS ABOUT 4,000 NOW, THAT HAVE DIED IN A SINCELESS WAR THAT SHOULD HAVE NEVER
    BEEN IN THE FIRST FIRST, AND ABOUT THE ENCONOMY WHICH IS GOING INTO A SERIOUS DEPRESSION IF SOMETHING DOESN’T CHANGE SOON! WORRY ABOUT
    SOMETHING THAT MAKES SINCE, NOT A NAME!

  64. The Silent Member in Church Says:

    On this article is funny to me…I know a few girls with names that I can’t spell and ironically one of the name appeared in the article. I wish i had her number that i can ask her how she spells her name…Now back to the main thought…I have to agree with the judge about black women naming their children with name that i can’t even pronounce or spell, but i don’t believe the government has to power to stop it because of the 1st. amendment.

  65. William Says:

    This is political satire… But apparently enough people agree with the point of the article to think it was actually real :)

  66. Marie says Says:

    Some nevre…

    Let me tell him what to name his children.

    He’s going just a little to far.

  67. Steve Says:

    This article is just a joke, people. But we as black folks DO need to chill out with the ridiculous names. Matter of fact, white Hollywood-types need to get back to basics, too. Bruce Willis & Demi Moore named their kids Rumor, Scout & Tallulah. WTF? Jason Lee named his kid Pilot Inspektor. Banjo? Moxie CrimeFighter? Apple? All names bestowed upon children now doomed to a life filled with wedgies, incessant teasing and multiple beatings. Sure you should be free to name your kids whatever you want, but have some sense; put down the crack pipe when you’re making that all-important decision.

  68. Crystal Says:

    Elizabeth…..Im coming to join you!
    Signed a grown ass black woman!
    If this is real- the devil is a liar and as far as the names!
    i feel we have way more important issues to deal with than some petty mess like this! I myself feel some names are over the top but hell it’s that persons child and with alittle guidence maybe we as a people can make things right!
    But whats with this 3 white women making choices for 1 black sista! Child please…..cant no white nothing tell me a damn thing …..They can assist me to grow in my area of career but after that it’s was great knowing you….dude

  69. Al the Bull Says:

    I think we are living in a world of change. This reflects change. Change should be allowed. If we are afraid of change, then change should be governed until we can except it.
    Let the names be. This is only change.

  70. jean Says:

    You fool of bull shit!!!!!!!!!
    A white woman must have named you!! and validated you!!. while i agree that some names are hard to spell and even harder to pronounce you are out of your flipping mind to even think of telling us we can only give names to our children if three white women determine the name is ok. You are looking for a riot when you try to take away our rights and put it into the hand of those who were our ancestor’s slave master. You fool!!!!!!!!. I am so outraged i am at a loss for words.

  71. Anonymous Says:

    well,
    there’s this thing called satire…

  72. Tron Says:

    This is copied, uncredited, from another site, http://thepeoplesnews.wordpress.com/2008/03/02/federal-judge-enough-with-the-stupid-names/. It’s parody, people, as is clearly identified in the original source.

  73. RJ Says:

    FALSE !! FALSE !! FALSE !! FALSE !! FALSE !!

    Please advise your friends

    http://www.snopes.com/humor/iftrue/blacknames.asp

  74. Sara Says:

    If teacher have such a hard time, why don’t they just asked the child. Ask the child how to say the name, and not what it means. I two children with African names. They may be hard to pronounce, but they have meaning. Maybe not at the kindegarden or first grade do they know the meaning of their name. As a parent I was busy teaching them their ABC’S and how to count. The basic they need to know for school. As they get older the meaning of their name become more important. If some of these teachers would stop tripping and listen it might not be that hard.

  75. LT Says:

    I don’t feel it should be up to 3 white people to agree, but at least 3 sensible adults of any race. If the name can be traced back to African roots then it should be good to go even if it sounds like nothing we’ve ever heard. I have 3 cousins with African names. I might not be able to spell them but I can pronounce them and they aren’t that outlandish (Akil, Ajanee, Bakari). I know students from Africa (Folasade pronounced shah-day and Ifoma).

    Will this also apply to Hispanics for example “Jesus” and “Concepcion” are not typical Anglo-Saxon “white” names.

    So although the judge made a ruling, he has not made it a law and that would have a process to go through before it is passed. I don’t like many of these unique names either but we as Americans are gratned some rights and some freedom. Federal, state and tax payer money should not be wasted fighting over this name game. The child can change their name when their old enough or go to court as this young lady did.

  76. STS Says:

    I am a black woman. I have an unfamiliar name but it is who I am. I know there is no one else like me. My identity isn’t negatively impacted because of what my mother named me. If I apply job for a job and you don’t hire me because you lack intelligence to pronounce it or immediately realize that I am black, then that job isnt for me and I probably wouldnt want to work in that environment anyway. More than likely people adjust to the mix ups as the years pass. I do plan to name my children with more prominent names. I would agree to the unfairness of someone else’s approval of what I name my child. If you arent the parents mind your own business. Society other than your own has no clue and are ignorant to your lifestyle and culture, and are envious that they have no creativity or lack the talent to come up with such names. They are capable of very cleverly manipulating every society to believe their way is the right way and brainwash everyone else to believe it is inappropriate. Stop trying to control everything and everybody. We are not clones or zombies. Learn how to be respectful.

  77. Anonymous Says:

    What about those who come to this country with names that are apart of they culture? I mean who are we to say that three WHITE people have to approve. I think thats BS!!!! I think it’s just a bias judge who has something against black women and want in implement another stupid law. I think there are other things to worry about than teachers having trouble pronouncing names. I mean really. Who appointed these ridiculous people in these position?!

  78. Manisha Says:

    I think it is outrageous and obscene for a Judge to put any type of
    ban on African American sounding names. It is completely
    uncostitutional. Names have been a sensitive issue in the Black
    community for quite some time. The issue is particularly sensitive for
    me because my name, Manisha, is Middle Eastern/ Indian and people
    always have difficulty pronouncing my name. The part that bothers me
    most when the issue is brought up is the fact that African American
    names are always singled out. No one would ever dare criticize
    Hispanic or Asian people for naming their children names that are
    traditional within their culture or names that may be difficult to
    read or pronounce. Furthermore, when Caucasions name their babies
    Apple, Cocoa, Rumour etc. no one calls them ghetto. But Sha’Quanna is
    ghetto? What about Condoleezza, Oprah, Beyonce, Montell, LeBron,
    Shaquille???? It is digusting that Black people are too stupid to see
    that the problem is not so much with the names as it is with the
    ignorance, discrimination and intolerance amoung others

  79. Trust God Says:

    Is it true or not? who knows, but as african american women when we are pregnant or befor we get pregnant we need to sit down and think about what do I want to name my child. Alot of us say we are christians we read the Bible, that is a good start to finding a name that means something, or looking back in our history at some of the people who actually made a difference in the community or in the world to name your child after. Regardless if we grew up in the hood or in a nicer area we shouldn’t name our children something they sometime can’t even pronounce or know the meaning of their name. And you know come judgement day God himself might not be able to pronounce it “Lol”. Speaking as a mother to other mothers and soon to be mothers think about it befor you name your child seek God on a name for your child. Be Blessed

  80. terrymum Says:

    Come on people.

    A. This is not a for real judge situation.

    B. All black people with half an ounce of sense know this situation is real. Those folks who choose to saddle their off-spring with a name that cannot be spelled, remembered or spoken by the vast majority of people are just asking for that child to suffer. Is it fair? No. Is it the way the world works? Yes.

    If you want to give your kid a unique name, please please please give them one normal name too. One they can use on work resumes. Otherwise, the racists of the world will have an easier time tossing THAT name into the “do not interview” file!!!

    Be smart – or don’t blame other people who notice you are dumb!

  81. Parents Fight Over Which Gang Toddler Should Join « Chatting With Lee Says:

    [...] realize that the Clitoria Jackson story was a satire.  I wish this one was, [...]

  82. Ebony Says:

    First of all, this story is SO BOGUS, I don’t know how anyone reading it on other websites or in their email ends up taking it seriously after reading it. The language is so loaded and lacks objectivity in a way that screams fake journalism.

    Second of all, if Clitoria were a person’s name (which it probably is somewhere in America), that person would be named after a genus of tropical flowers. Just because the person reading it is ignorant of its meaning doesn’t mean their mother or father didn’t have the right to give her child that name. I must say that I have seen some names that have made me cringe, but I would never advocate for taking away a person’s right to name their child whatever they please. I am most certainly in favor of parents giving their children names that actually have meanings, even if the parents themselves have signified the meaning.

    Teachers and other people can’t pronounce a lot of names, but that also often has to do with the fact that we as Americans are averse to anything that doesn’t look like English and haven’t taken the time to learn or respect other languages. Mutaqee (pronounced: moo-TOC-ee) actually means “pious one” and has way more meaning than “hound-lover” (the meaning of Connor), but lacking respect for other cultures or for the fact that non-English names can actually have valid significance, most of us would want to cuss Mutaqee’s mother out, too, not taking into consideration that perhaps she wanted a child with a meaningful name, not just a name that was “acceptable”…and acceptable to WHO? Chances are MOST people’s parents don’t even know what their names mean, “acceptable” and “normal” as they may be. There are plenty of mommas who didn’t know they were naming their child “hound-lover” when they gave them the name Connor.

    I would encourage people to slow their roll when they make judgement on a person’s name. Instead of sayin’, “What the hell kinda name is that?!” ask a person what their name means or why their parents named them that. You’d be surprised at the stories you’ll get that go a lot deeper than picking something out of a baby names book or beyond “They thought that people wouldn’t know my ethnicity (might even think I was white) when they saw my name on my resume.”

    P.S. Lucretia is actually an elite, Southern white name. I’ve come across this name for rich, older white women quite often in my work.

  83. Jim Says:

    I think the Judge’s solution is really “uneeqqi.”

    And that is a TWENTY-TWO year old doing with SEVEN kids anyway?

    The story says she’s on welfare, too. Why should taxpayers have to pay a nickel to support someone like that who is just a taker.

  84. Alicia Says:

    http://www.snopes.com/humor/iftrue/blacknames.asp

    check this website out. But this is good for conversation. Maybe if it’s passed around enough, others will have something to think about before naming their childern. The question or statement I did read was about the childs future in working world. Would you hire a person with a BA times 3 and 4 more PH, DDS following their name, a resume’ that would make Donald, Oprah, Bill take a 2nd or 3rd look to run your company? How would you call them back if you can’t pronounce their names?

  85. james bell Says:

    maybe the judge will attack the rights of Asians next!

  86. maxwell Says:

    This law shall never been implemented. I disagreed ,How an what makes three white woman have the right to say what your child shall be name. God an only God can judge us .
    I no as african american Woman that some of are names can be hard too say learn an do not ask a six or seven yesr old what their name means

    Judge me not

  87. Anita Says:

    I can’t believe that in this day and time a Judge can create such a discriminatory law like this. I do agree with him as far as the ridiculous names that these parents created and do not have meanings, but I would have never thought he could get away with it. You should never ever give your child a name that doesn’t have a meaning.
    God help them all!

  88. Judge Changes Child’s Name (A True Story) « Chatting With Lee Says:

    [...] about a federal judge that ruled that a mother was not legally able to name her child Clitoria (see post).  The responses to this satirical posting were amazing.  (In fact, I think that posting has more [...]

  89. tonip Says:

    While looking for websites about bad names I came across this article. I work at a newspaper taking death notices so I have seen some names for the books. What amazes me though almost as much as some of the names out there is how many people don’t get SATIRE! Come on people get real! No federal judge could possibly make such a ruling. I’m not a lawyer and I know it’s absurd on any number of levels. Think before you start spouting off about something like this and look at the point the author was trying to make.

  90. Jim Says:

    Guys, guys, guys…

    This is a parody. That means “joke.”

    I am a radiologist in a small Southern hospital. You should see the names that I see on a daily basis in the process of reading 120 x-rays.

    What these people don’t realize is that they are ruining their children’s chances for success in life. I save these names for fun and my most recent acquisition was “D’ernya.” Durn ya! Do you think I would risk my business by hiring someone with a name like that? All I would be thinking at the interview is how ignorant his family must have been, and wonder what kind of grief he would bring my practice.

    Not for me. Sorry. You’re out of business, son. See me when you get a proper name.

    Jim


Leave a Reply